WATCH precipitation and snowfall (1958-2001)


Posted by Lila Warszawski on Dec. 4, 2014

A truncation error during processing of the WATCH data resulted in daily values of total precipitation and snowfall for the period 1958-2001 being decreased to integer mm/day values. As a result, accumulated monthly precipitation has been reduced by up to 10mm in some months and regions.

The problems were with the WATCH data set only, but because the WATCH+WFDEI data set also includes these data, the latter data set was also affected

Although the differences in total precipitation are below 10% in many areas, they reach 10-20% for large regions like Siberia and North-West America (and up to several tens of percent in low precipitation areas), and we consider these errors to be sufficiently severe to warrant re-running your simulations for the WATCH and WATCH+WFDEI data sets.

The figures below (click for hi-res) show multi-year (1958-2001) monthly means of absolute and relative differences between the old and the fixed WATCH data for total precipitation and snowfall (don't mind the year 2001 given in the figure headers, it refers to the last time step in the NetCDF files only).

Relative differences in Precipitation (rain + snowfall)

pr_diff_old-new_rel.png

Absolute differences in Precipitation (rain + snowfall)

pr_diff_old-new_abs.png

Relative differences in Snowfall

prsn_diff_old-new_rel.pdf

Absolute differences in Snowfall

prsn_diff_old-new_abs.png

Long wave radiation and humidity were also affected by a less dramatic truncation problem, resulting in monthly mean differences of less than 1%. All other variables have not been affected by the truncation error.

Furthermore, we have come across anomalies in the wind field for approximately 20 days in 1978 in the original WATCH data. We are in contact with the developers of the data set.

Additionally, pixels in the two easternmost columns (179.25E and 179.75W) of our data were shifted by one latitude to the south.